Monday, September 11, 2006

Technically, carbon-free competitive energy may not be so hard

I was recently surprised to find how low operating costs can be for wind energy. At suitable sites, operating costs after initial depreciation (only three years for payback on a wind tower in some cases) are now below those of thermal power, as evidenced by the fact that wind energy is being installed in India and China where the environment is hardly considered at all. This is for average utilisation, allowing for when the wind does not blow. The latter is limiting factor on the proportion of power which can be generated by wind, not its costs - there has to be back up power for windless days.

This report
indicates that in Australia, at suitable sites (coastal sites in the very hot N.W Australian desert) a solar thermal energy tower could produce electricity for under 4.5c/KWh, virtually all the amortisation of capital costs. Even if initally out by a factor of 2, then with a normal experience curve, it looks pretty competitive. The best sites are a long way from consumers, except in a few places like southern Spain and southern California, but as discussed in the last blog the best potential for this technology is to make cheap ammonia for fuel

It may prove to be cheaper and easier, with limited technical risk, to replace carbon fuels without resorting to the difficulties of carbon sequestration or nuclear power (although I do regard the latter as the lesser of two evils compared to CO2 emissions). It just requires will, enormous investment, and above all sufficiently high long term price signals for carbon fuels. This probably does require carbon taxes otherwise coal replaces oil, and coal is even worse for carbon emissions - but at the cost numbers above, perhaps not.

So why are we risking destroying the world if it is not so hard to solve? Inertia, ignorance, vested interests and more charitably huge risks on future prices to evaluate projects. If governments across the world (and especially America and China) are serious about a "Manhattan project" on energy, then underwriting this risk may be the best way to proceed

While ammonia does look like a good substitute for gasoline and diesel for land and sea transport, upon reflection the numbers do not add up so well for aviation. Some sort of biofuel may have to be a second best here.

I doubt if "peak oil" will help in time. Raw materials running out is very rare. There is probably plenty of unexploited oil in Russia, and in Saudi, Aramco still caps wells when they stop producing under natural pressure i.e when plenty is left underground. In any case the danger is that China and India especially would then turn even more to coal, even worse for carbon emissions than oil. This chilling article (no pun intended) reinforces the idea that we must act in the next ten years, and cannot depend on the unaided help of energy markets.

Labels: ,

Thursday, August 10, 2006

More on Ammonia

The Engineer Poet is dismissive of chemical energy transporters for renewable energy, whether hydrogen or ammonia (which after all, is a convenient way of transporting hydrogen). He has a point: direct use of electricity in, for example, fuel cells has much better efficiencies and therefore shouldbe cheaper.

Certainly generating electricity and then producing hydrogen by electrolysis is not on, in efficiency or cost terms. For thermochemical production of hydrogen using S-I or Ca-Br as a catalyst, however, from solar heat or off-peak nuclear, theoretical efficiencies are in the 40-50% range, which compares with electricity generation. These technologies have not yet been developed outside the lab. Why? –because steam cracking of natural gas to make hydrogen (the process used today) is 70-80% efficient, but that produces CO2, and would be pointless for a fuel anyway (just use the natural gas directly)

The key fact however is that there will be a continued need for chemical storage of energy . Most renewables are intermittent and/or a long way from the consumer, given long distance power transmission losses (or not even feasible – Australian solar power sold to China?) Direct distribution and storage of hydrogen is a nightmare. There seems no potential alternative for planes to a chemical fuel, and the elites of the world would rather wreck the world’s climate than give up flying. Yes, oil is a better storage medium than ammonia, but if anyone can come up with a better alternative that does not have those dratted C atoms somewhere in the molecule, please let me know.

Theoretical efficiency isn’t everything, otherwise the internal combustion engine and the steam turbine would be long gone. We have been promised fuel cells and high capacity traction batteries for decades – where are they? The world has got to change its whole energy and transportation within two decades or we are climatically wrecked - the less technological change or technical risk involved, the more likely this is to happen. This path minimises the risk, even if it less than ideally efficient.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, August 08, 2006

The Ammonia Economy

There has been a lot of discussion about "the hydrogen economy" as an alternative to fossil fuels. Some people think it is an alternative energy source, while it is just a transmission medium, and not, in my opinion, a very good one.

The great advantage is that it burns cleanly to produce only water.This is outweighed by the numerous disadvantages. Energy density is low, it would take three times as much hydrogen through a pipeline as natural gas to transmit the same amount of energy. Moreover hydrogen makes normal pipeline steel brittle, and although in theory it works in internal combustion engines, the same embrittlement problem occurs. Liquefaction is horribly difficult (the lightest element of all only liquifies below -200deg C) and although it can be stored in metal hydrides, a hydride fuel tank would weigh a lot and have limited capacity. Hydrogen is highly explosive

There is however an alternative. Ammonia is easily made from nitrogen and hydrogen with an iron catalyst by the Haber-Bosch process and widely used to make fertilisers. It is easily liquefied (-33deg C, a higher temperature than natural gas) and easily and safely transported, by tanker, ship or pipeline - there are already extensive ammonia pipelines in the US to serve agriculture. It does not burn in air at atmospheric pressure, but will do so readily with air under compression, in either an internal combustion engine or a gas turbine (including jet engines). In fact it is a better fuel than petrol(gasoline) with an octane rating of 130 and delivering 10-20% more power than petrol. It burns cleanly to water and nitrogen, the latter accounting for three quarters of the atmosphere anyway. Surprisingly, it produces less nitrogen oxide emissions than petrol or diesel.

There are two disadvantages. While engine power is enhanced, fuel consumption by weight is two to three times higher. The biggest problem is that it is poisonous in moderately high concentrations. It dissipates rapidly in air, however, and has been safely used and transported on farms across the world for years, and its distinctive smell is very strong long before the concentration reaches dangerous levels. We also forget how used we have become to the dangers of petrol and natural gas: our cars are flying bombs travelling at up to 100mph, while ammonia does not burn in open air.

It is also quite cheap. Currently the bulk price for ammonia in dry liquid form is $250-300/metric ton, sharply up on two years ago as over 80% of the costs of production are from natural gas, which is used to make the hydrogen. Taking into account enhanced power from engines and lower miles per gallon, the cost in petrol equivalent terms is around $3 per US gallon, very much the same as US gasoline prices today (actual ammonia costs are two and half times lower).

Current hydrogen production uses natural gas, but there is interesting potential with solar thermal power. Such high temperatures can be generated with solar power that hydrogen can be produced thermochemically, several catalytic reactions being available to assist this (sulpur-iodine, calcium-bromine). If costs of solar thermal power generation can be halved - should be possible with scale, experience, and mass production, then the cost of generating the hydrogen becomes comprable to present day costs from natural gas cracking. The hydrogen then feeds an adjoining ammonia plant. The intermittent nature of solar power does not matter for liquid fuel production, unlike electricity production

The other point is that nearly all the costs of solar thermal are capital costs, and depreciated plants after 15-20 years would be very low cost, compared to today and still more so compared to post-peak oil. Apart from some of the hydrogen cracking catalysis (still in the lab) everything else in the process is either proven or low tech. Above all it is a feasible way to fuel existing land, sea and air engines. The great greeen panaceas of fuel cells and high performance batteries have been so long in development and with so little success that one remains dubious. It is the only way I can think of, to provide carbon-free flight.

Whaat is needed to replace oil for transport? About 15-20sq.kms of hot desert land near the sea (to get the water for hydrogen - sea water will do)for the energy equivalent of one large electric power station, which is not excessive. Southern Spain, Morocco, large parts of the Middle East; Southern California, northern Mexico; western Australia, eastern India (Thar desert); S.W. Africa, northern Chile - there is a long list.

Labels: ,

Monday, August 07, 2006

Quick thoughts on "alternative" energy costs

I have been doing some research on the issues of costs, scale,sustainability and short term feasibility. Some very quick thoughts, if anyone wants to look further there is plenty on the web. The "benchmark" electricity generation would be costs at an efficient fluidised bed coal fired power station, some where around 3-6 USc/KWh, depending on location, gas fired generally a bit higher (and up to double a year or two ago) but more flexible and suitable for peak power.

Hydro: drowns valleys but otherwise wonderful, cheap but available resources used up long ago.

Biomass: am I alone in thinking this a short term kludge? At best carbon neutral, good farmland will be in short supply in the global greenhouse, and will encourage deforestation. Utilising wastes like woodchips and straw will be more helpful, but this will not solve world energy problem except at the margin

Wind: not so much higher cost than fossil fuel when the wind blows at the right strength, and a rapid advance in turbine technology, but just so unreliable: even if the wind is too strong (over 25 metres/sec) blades have to feathered and power drops. Even in Denmark, a fairly windy place and the biggest per head investor in wind farms, special connections to Scandinavian hydro grid are in place for when the wind does not blow, and capacity utilisation is around 30%, no better than solar. Massacres birds.

Tidal power: limited sites and environmental issues (turbines in tidal estuaries rather than barrages can alleviate some of these). Needs a lot more research. Great potential for the UK, especially Severn estuary

Wave power: lots of potential, but too early to develop. Big inherent problems with storm damage

Solar photovoltaics. Horrible costs, even allowing for a normal halving on "experience curve" as technology matures, still far too high for mass power generation. Exotic cells use rare elements like gallium, those using more common materials (essentially crystalline or amorphous silicon)have an efficiency limit of 10-15% per cent.

Geothermal: limited sites in volcanic areas where underwater superheated reservoirs can be exploited, attractive costs where they are, but even then no truly renewable. Sites are "harvested" in a few decades, and prolonging life by water injection has problems e.g water disappears down fissures, or can even cause earthquakes. Not everyone can live in Iceland. The really interesting development is hot dry rocks. At certain locations (not sure how prevalent, there is test development in Australia and Germany)naturally mildly radioactive granites at up to 5km depth (the limit for commercial drilling technology) are overlain with impermeable rocks and have a temperature gradient of 40deg c/km instead of the normal 30. Inject water down under pressure to fracture the rock, and pump up again at temperatures of around 200 deg C to drive turbines. Far too experimental to be developed, so costs cannot even be estimated yet, but has the potential to be developed quite rapidly

Solar thermal: either a mass array of parabolic reflectors heating up water or another fluid, or hot air from a greenhouse array being conducted up a solar tower where it drives turbines. Works well in desert mid latitudes (20-40degrees of latitude, plenty of that around the world). Operating costs two to three times normal power costs, mainly because unit capital costs so high (plant only used at peak power for 30% of time) and power obviously intermittent. However there is interesting potential to bypass power generation entirely, with much greater efficiencies: temperatures generated are so high that it can be used to split water into hydrogen and oxygen thermochemically.

More about this in a subsequent post, and more about the obvious two medium term solutions, carbon capture at thermal power stations (sequestration) and nuclear

Labels: ,

Saturday, February 26, 2005

Cleaning Up The Environment: The Gradual Way

There are plenty of alternative technologies to burning carbon fuels to generate power, all of them with drawbacks, and generally lower efficiencies and higher costs. I do not want to debate here the relative merits of solar, wind , nuclear etc. but simply to look at what sort of system is needed to make sure that the world economy is incentivised to improve them and reduce carbon emissions. Burning fossil fuels and capturing the carbon dioxide may be quickest step forward anyway: not ideal, but better than nothing (probably by reinjecting into spent oil and gas reservoirs, where it may have the added benefit of improving oil recovery rates) .

Firstly an effective system should as far as possible use market mechanisms , essentially carbon taxes and credits. On a global scale regulation without market incentives simply leads to cheating, bad implementation, and corruption. There will be some of the latter with market mechanisms, but less so as decisions are decentralised and self-interest comes into play. Nevertheless certain conditions have to be met .

Examine the world free trade set-up (today, the WTO, and its predecessor GATT). Why does it work?
- it is in the self interest of any one country to introduce free trade even if all others do not: as long as other countries are willing to trade. In other words, it does not need everyone to take part for the system to work
- it is in the interest of countries to join up even if others are more efficient at everything they produce (Ricardo's theory of comparative advantage: a neat way of showing that economics is not all bullshit, as it is both true and non-obvious). This means all parties gain, there are no absolute losers
- advantages are progressive. A bit of cheating through susidies, non-tarriff barriers etc. will not wreck the system, as long as it is not too bad
- an important consideration is that there is at least one power who is strong enough to police the system. In the case of free trade, it is actually two, the USA and the EU. Both of them are generally for free trade, despite some glaring omissions in areas like agriculture and steel, and thus usually if reluctantly obey WTO rulings. In the case of the USA, WTO rulings are thus the only international law which is accepted to have precedence over the will of Congress (although it is doubtful if Congress realises or will admit the fact)

These two players are powerful enough to use sticks as well as carrots to get others who sign up to obey the rules, and incentivise non-members to join or even shadow the behaviour of members.

What about a global emissions system (whether Kyoto or something different). Not everybody has to join, but the major emitters do; too much freeloading wrecks the system. The biggest problem is that it does pay to freeload: you would be an absolute winner if you had no emission controls and everybody else (or even the majority) do. Thus policing of the system has to be more coercive, more akin to punishing lawbreakers than to maintaining the WTO.

Essentially it depends on America- without it nothing can be driven through, including getting rising economic powers like China to take part as well. Not only does the US emit 25% of global carbon dioxide for only 4% of the popluation, at twice the rate per head of Europe or Japan, but the right which is now in power is virulently anti-environmental. The key is any change of attitude among Republican voters, and it is not hopeless . Even some green evangelical groups (the What would Jesus drive? constituency ) are emerging. The problem is to convince them that global warming has nothing to do with other issues on liberal agendas. Too early to despair.

Labels: ,